Home - Power Supply Knowledges - Flicker, Ghosting and Dead Dimmers: Getting Phase-Cut Dimming Right With LED Drivers
Flicker, Ghosting and Dead Dimmers: Getting Phase-Cut Dimming Right With LED Drivers
A restaurant refit in Copenhagen, forty 12 W downlights on eight two-wire dimmers, and three complaints within a week: the lights glow faintly when switched off, they flicker at the bottom of the dimming range, and two of the dimmers have stopped working entirely. The electrician has replaced the dimmers once. The lighting designer blames the drivers. The driver supplier blames the dimmers.
All three symptoms have the same root cause, and it is neither the dimmer nor the driver in isolation. It is the interaction between a phase-cut dimmer designed in 1975 for a resistive load and a driver that presents a capacitive, non-linear load with a minimum operating threshold. Once you see the mechanism, the symptoms stop being mysterious and start being predictable — and preventable, at the specification stage, for the price of a different dimmer or a different control method.
How a phase-cut dimmer thinks the world works
A leading-edge (TRIAC) dimmer works by chopping the leading part of each half-cycle. It waits until the mains voltage crosses a threshold, then fires a TRIAC that conducts for the rest of the half-cycle, and the TRIAC turns off at the next zero crossing. The longer it waits, the less energy reaches the load.
This works beautifully with an incandescent lamp, which is a pure resistor. The current follows the voltage, the TRIAC stays latched because the current stays above its holding current, and the lamp dims smoothly from 100% to about 5%.
Now connect an LED driver. The driver’s input is a bridge rectifier and a capacitor, so it does not draw current continuously — it draws a short, tall pulse near the peak of the voltage, when the capacitor voltage is below the rectified mains. The consequences, in order:
- The TRIAC may not latch. If the load current at the firing instant is below the TRIAC’s holding current (typically 10–50 mA), it fires and immediately turns off, then fires again on the next attempt. The result is unstable firing and visible flicker, worst at low dim levels where the conduction angle is smallest.
- The inrush through the dimmer is enormous. A driver’s capacitor charges in under a millisecond, and the dimmer’s TRIAC sees a current spike of tens of amps. A 400 W dimmer with a 25 A surge rating may survive a few hundred of these. The two dead dimmers in Copenhagen died of this, not of overload.
- The output is not clean. Because the driver’s input is chopped, its output carries the chopped waveform’s low-frequency content, and unless the driver has a large enough output capacitor and a slow enough loop, that appears as flicker at 100 Hz.
Trailing-edge dimmers replace the TRIAC with a MOSFET or IGBT that switches off at the start of the half-cycle rather than on, which suits capacitive loads much better and avoids the latching problem. They cost two to three times as much, they are less common in retrofit situations, and they still require a minimum load.
The glow when switched off is not a fault
The most common complaint, and the one most often misdiagnosed as a defective driver, is the faint glow when the switch is off.
A two-wire dimmer has no neutral connection. Its internal electronics — the microcontroller, the radio if it is smart, the LED indicator — need power, and the only path available is through the load. So it leaks a small current, typically 0.3 to 2 mA, through the lamp even when it is “off”.
An incandescent lamp ignores this: 1 mA through a 60 W filament produces nothing visible. An LED driver does not ignore it. That leakage current charges the driver’s input capacitor until it reaches the startup threshold, the driver briefly starts, the capacitor discharges into the LEDs, the voltage falls, the driver stops. The cycle repeats a few times a second. You see a faint flicker or a steady dim glow, and you have a driver that is behaving exactly as designed, powered by a current it was never meant to receive.
The fix is not a different driver. It is one of:
- A dimmer with a neutral connection. The cleanest solution, and the reason smart dimmers increasingly require a neutral. It costs a wire, which in a retrofit is often the whole problem.
- A driver with a higher startup threshold and a bleeder circuit that keeps the input below the threshold at these tiny currents. This is a design feature, and it is one of the things that separates a “dimmable” driver from a “phase-cut compatible” one.
- A small permanent bleed load across the output, sized to swamp the dimmer’s leakage. It works, and it wastes 0.5–1 W forever in every fixture.
The third option is what most installers do at 4 p.m. on the last day, and it is why retrofit projects end up with a resistor behind every downlight. It solves the symptom and doubles the standby consumption of the fixture.
The minimum load number nobody reads
Dimmer datasheets have two ratings, and buyers read the wrong one.
A typical wall dimmer says “400 W” in large type and “LED: 100 W max, 10 W min” in small type. The 400 W figure is the incandescent rating — a resistive load. The LED rating is roughly a quarter of it, because the current waveform is spiky and the thermal stress on the TRIAC is much higher for the same wattage.
The minimum is the number that causes the flicker complaints. A dimmer needs a minimum load to keep its own electronics powered and to keep the TRIAC latched. That minimum is usually 10–25 W for a modern LED-compatible dimmer and can be 40 W for an older one.
Now do the arithmetic on a real project: eight 6 W downlights on one dimmer is 48 W, which is fine. Four 6 W downlights is 24 W, which is at the edge. Two 6 W downlights is 12 W, which is below the minimum on many dimmers, and the customer dims to 20%, which reduces the effective load further, and the flicker starts.
This is why the same downlight works in one room and flickers in another with the same dimmer model. It is a load-count problem, not a product problem.
The practical rule: treat the dimmer’s stated minimum LED load as a hard floor, add 50% margin, and check the count at the lowest dim level you will actually use. If the fixture is a 6 W downlight with a 5% minimum dim, four units is not four times 6 W of margin — it is 24 W of load being asked to operate a dimmer that needs 25 W.
What a “phase-cut compatible” driver actually contains
Not all dimmable drivers are equal, and the difference is visible in the circuit.
A driver that is merely “dimmable” may accept a chopped input and translate it into a dim level, but with a narrow input range, no bleeder, and a control loop that becomes unstable at low conduction angles. It will work on a bench with a resistive load bank and fail in a room with four downlights.
A driver designed for phase-cut dimming adds three things:
- A bleeder circuit that presents a minimum load to the dimmer at the start of each half-cycle, keeping the TRIAC latched. This is the single most important feature, and it is why two drivers with the same dimming range can behave completely differently.
- A wide input range with hold-up, so that a chopped waveform with a long off-period does not drop the driver below its undervoltage lockout.
- A slow output loop that filters the 100 Hz envelope rather than amplifying it, so the LEDs see a smoothed current instead of a chopped one.
Our 100W constant voltage dimmable driver and the 60W 3-in-1 dimmable power supply both include a bleeder and are specified down to a 5% minimum dim with a stated minimum load, because the number of support calls we used to get about flicker at 10% was the reason we added it. The 3-in-1 models accept phase-cut, 0-10 V and PWM on the same input, which means a project can start with the existing dimmer and move to 0-10 V later without changing the fixture.
When to stop fighting and change the control method
Phase-cut dimming exists because the wiring exists. In a retrofit where the walls are painted and the switch drops are two-core, it is the only option and the engineering effort goes into making it stable.
In new-build, it is the wrong choice almost every time. Compare:
| Phase-cut (leading) | Phase-cut (trailing) | 0-10 V | DALI | |
| Extra wiring | None | None | 2-core control | 2-core control |
| Minimum load | 10–25 W per dimmer | 10–25 W | None | None |
| Dimming range | 5–10% typical | 1–5% | 1–100% | 0.1–100% |
| Flicker at low dim | Common | Occasional | Rare | Rare |
| Per-fixture address | No | No | No | Yes |
| Cost per zone | Low | Medium | Medium | High |
If the project has a ceiling void and a lighting designer, 0-10 V costs about €1.20 per fixture in cable and gives you a dimming range that does not depend on how many lamps are on the circuit. If the project has 200 fixtures and needs scheduling or fault reporting, DALI. If the project is a retrofit with two-core cable and a client who wants to keep the existing dimmers, phase-cut is the pragmatic answer — but specify the driver as phase-cut compatible, state the minimum load, and count the fixtures per dimmer before the order, not after.
The three-question diagnostic
When a site has a dimming complaint, these three questions identify the cause in about five minutes:
- How many watts are on each dimmer, and what is the dimmer’s stated LED minimum? If the answer is “eight 6 W lamps on a 100 W dimmer with a 25 W minimum”, you have found it. Combine the circuits or change the dimmer.
- Does the glow appear with the dimmer switched off, and does the dimmer have a neutral? If it glows and there is no neutral, it is leakage. A neutral-connected dimmer or a driver with a bleeder solves it.
- Does the flicker appear only below 20% dim? That is the bottom of the conduction range, where the TRIAC’s holding current and the driver’s loop are both marginal. Either raise the minimum dim in the controller, or accept that this dimmer and this driver do not go that low together.
If the answer to all three is “yes”, the installation is not faulty. It is a compatibility mismatch that no amount of replacement will fix, because the replacement will have the same characteristics on both sides.
FAQ
Why does my LED light glow faintly when the switch is off? The dimmer is a two-wire type with no neutral, so it powers its own electronics by leaking 0.3–2 mA through the lamp. An incandescent bulb ignores that; an LED driver’s capacitor charges until the driver briefly starts, producing a glow or a slow flicker. Fit a dimmer with a neutral, or a driver with a bleeder circuit.
Why does my LED flicker only at low dim levels? At small conduction angles the dimmer’s TRIAC may not stay latched, and the driver’s control loop is operating far from its design point. Below about 20% dim, most phase-cut systems are marginal. Check the dimmer’s minimum load first, then the driver’s stated minimum dim.
Can I use a 400 W dimmer with 400 W of LED load? No. The 400 W figure is the incandescent rating. The LED rating is typically a quarter of it — 100 W — because the current waveform is spiky and stresses the TRIAC thermally. Check the small print, not the big number.
Do I need a special dimmable driver or will any dimmable one work? You need one specified for phase-cut input, with a bleeder circuit and a stated minimum load. “Dimmable” alone may mean 0-10 V or PWM only, and connecting a phase-cut dimmer to a 0-10 V input does nothing at best.
Is 0-10 V better than phase-cut? For new-build, yes: no minimum load, wider range, less flicker. It needs a two-core control cable, which is why retrofits stay on phase-cut. The driver can often support both, so specify the dual-input version if the site may upgrade.
Specifying dimming for a retrofit with existing dimmers? The 100W constant voltage dimmable driver and the 60W 3-in-1 dimmable power supply both carry a bleeder circuit and a published minimum load, and the 3-in-1 models run phase-cut, 0-10 V and PWM from the same input — so a site can start where the wiring is and move later. Send the dimmer model and the fixture count per circuit and we will tell you whether it will be stable before you buy.